Which Smart Lock Should You Buy? What 20 Locks Across 3 Homes Taught Me

Illustration of a dark front door with a keypad smart lock and a phone app showing the door locked

Short answer: a keypad deadbolt with Wi-Fi and AA batteries. Mine is the Yale Assure Lock 2.

Real answer: For most Seattle homeowners, I recommend a keypad deadbolt with built-in Wi-Fi that runs on AA batteries. The Yale Assure Lock 2 with Wi-Fi is the one I put on my own doors. Want to keep your outside hardware and keys? A retrofit like August goes on the inside only. The real differences are battery life, how the lock reaches the internet, and whether your phone can be the key.

20Smart locks across my 3 homes
3 vs 12Months of rated battery: August vs Yale
4 wksOf daily low-battery emails before a far-off lock got fresh batteries

Smart lock matcher

Which smart lock fits your door?

Tap your situation. The match updates as you tap, with my pick, a runner-up, a battery plan and a setup list. Nothing you pick leaves this page.

Which door?
Your deadbolt
What matters most?
Your phones
Wi-Fi at the door

Your setup list

0 of 0 done

    General homeowner information from my own doors and each maker’s product page (see Sources). Ratings are the makers’ own; I don’t take money from any lock brand.

    I run smart locks on a Seattle home, a lake house and a golf-course place. They’re August, Yale and Schlage, plus a few I tried and pulled. Everything below is either from the maker’s own page or from living with these locks through Seattle winters.

    Same thing, other names: smart lock, smart deadbolt, keyless entry, keypad door lock, electronic or digital door lock, Wi-Fi lock. A retrofit smart lock replaces only the inside half of a deadbolt you already have.

    Start here

    Pick the type of smart lock first, then the brand

    5 kinds of smart lock sit on Seattle front doors. The type decides most of what you live with: the look from the street, the batteries, and whether you can still use a key.

    RetrofitInside half only. Your keys and outside look stay.August, Nuki, Level Bolt
    Keypad deadboltButtons or touchscreen outside, motor inside.Yale Assure Lock 2, Schlage Encode Plus, Kwikset Aura Reach
    FingerprintA reader on the keypad. Handy for kids.Yale Assure Lock 2 Touch
    HiddenLooks like a plain deadbolt. Battery sits inside the bolt.Level Lock Pro
    No keywayCode, phone or watch only. USB-C jump if the batteries die.Schlage Sense Pro
    The 5 kinds of smart lock, from least to most change on your door.
    TypeWhat changesKeysBest for
    RetrofitInside half of the deadboltYour keys still workRenters, condos, doors you don’t want to change
    Keypad deadboltThe whole deadboltUsually one key cylinderMost homes; guest and family codes
    FingerprintThe whole deadboltUsually a key cylinderKids and people who forget codes
    Hidden (Level)The whole deadboltComes with keysClean look, Apple households
    No keyway (Sense Pro)The whole deadboltNone; USB-C jumpstartHands-free iPhone unlock

    My rule: if you love your current hardware or rent your home, go retrofit. If you want a code pad for family, dog walkers or guests, go keypad deadbolt.

    What I run

    My picks after running 20 smart locks

    Here’s where each brand landed in my homes. Everything marked “I run it” is on one of my doors today. The rest I’ve tested, passed on, or only know from the maker’s spec sheet.

    OUTSIDEINSIDEdoor sensor
    1. 1Outside: keypad and a key cylinder (most models)
    2. 2Inside: motor, batteries and the thumbturn
    3. 3Radio: Wi-Fi, Bluetooth or Thread
    4. 4Door sensor: tells auto-lock the door is shut
    Outside you see a keypad; inside sits the motor, the batteries, the radio and, on the better locks, a door sensor.
    August Wi-Fi smart lock with a green status light on Brian Huie’s Seattle front door, inside view
    August on my Seattle door: nothing shows outside.
    Schlage keypad smart deadbolt on a dark gray front door
    Schlage: built like a vault.
    Finger pressing the keypad of a Yale Assure smart lock on a dark door
    Yale Assure Lock 2: my pick for most homes.
    Hand holding a deadbolt whose bolt holds the battery, next to a door edge
    Battery inside the bolt: the design I pass on.
    4 of my own doors and one I passed on.
    I run itYale Assure Lock 2 with Wi-Fi

    The one I recommend to most homeowners. AA batteries, Wi-Fi built in, a reliable app, and DoorSense so auto-lock knows the door is actually shut. On my multi-home setup, Yale and August sit in one app. Its only miss: Apple Home Key needs the Plus model.

    I run itSchlage

    My longtime favorite for plain toughness. If locks were cars, Schlage is the Land Cruiser. The Encode Plus carries BHMA’s top AAA rating and Apple Home Key. Schlage says alkaline AA only, never lithium.

    I run itAugust Wi-Fi Smart Lock

    The minimalist’s lock. It replaces only the inside, so the outside of my Seattle door stays clean and my keys still work. The trade: 2 CR123 batteries rated up to 3 months, and a chunky inside housing.

    PassedLevel Lock Pro

    Beautiful, and it looks like a normal deadbolt. Level rates it BHMA AAA and ANSI Grade 1. I still don’t love a battery living inside the bolt on doors I own or manage.

    PassedKwikset

    2 older Kwikset models in 2 homes gave me jams, a loud grind and quick battery drain. The newer Aura Reach (Matter over Thread, ANSI Grade 2) is a different lock. I haven’t lived with it.

    On paperSchlage Sense Pro, Nuki

    Sense Pro (June 2026) unlocks hands-free with an iPhone and has no keyway at all. Nuki retrofits US deadbolts with no drilling and rates up to 12 months on Thread. Promising; not on my doors yet.

    LockBattery (maker’s rating)ConnectionPhone as keyRatingMy status
    Yale Assure Lock 2 Wi-Fi4 AA, up to 1 yearWi-Fi built inPlus model only (Apple Home Key)ANSI/BHMA Grade 2I run it
    Schlage Encode Plus4 AA alkaline, up to 6 monthsWi-Fi built inApple Home KeyBHMA AAAI run Schlage
    Schlage Sense Pro4 AA, up to 6 monthsWi-Fi + Matter over ThreadHands-free Apple home key; Aliro-readyNo keywayOn paper
    August Wi-Fi Smart Lock2 CR123, up to 3 monthsWi-Fi built inApp and Apple WatchRetrofitI run it
    Nuki Smart LockUp to 12 months on Thread (6 on Wi-Fi)MatterAppRetrofitOn paper
    Level Lock Pro1 CR2 in the bolt, up to 1 yearMatter over ThreadApple Home KeyBHMA AAA, Grade 1Passed
    Kwikset Aura Reach4 AAMatter over ThreadAppANSI/BHMA Grade 2Older models: passed

    Ratings and battery figures are the makers’ own, from their product pages. Real battery life runs shorter on a busy door and in cold weather.

    Batteries

    Battery life is the real cost of a smart lock

    Every smart lock on the market runs on batteries. The rating on the box assumes a quiet door and mild weather. A busy front door, Wi-Fi left on and a wet Seattle winter all cut into it.

    Yale Assure Lock 212 mo
    Level Lock Pro12 mo
    Nuki (Thread)12 mo
    Schlage Encode Plus6 mo
    Schlage Sense Pro6 mo
    Nuki (Wi-Fi)6 mo
    August Wi-Fi3 mo
    Rated battery life, in months, from each maker’s page. “Up to” means best case.

    What a dying battery looks like

    At my lake house and golf-course place, I’ve had locks email me “battery low” every day for about 4 weeks before the batteries got swapped. If a door is far from you, pick the longest-rated battery and change it on a calendar, not on a warning.

    1. 1Match the battery type. Schlage says its locks aren’t compatible with lithium batteries; August asks for CR123 lithium and no rechargeables.
    2. 2Change them before winter. Yale notes extreme cold and heat affect battery performance, so fresh batteries in fall beat a warning in January.
    3. 3Calendar it. Put the next change on your calendar the day you install fresh ones.
    4. 4Keep a spare set by the door. Most low-battery warnings give you days, not hours, of runway.

    Connection

    Wi-Fi, bridges, Thread and Matter in plain words

    Your phone talks to the lock one of 3 ways. All 3 work; they differ in what else you need and how fast the batteries drain.

    Built-in Wi-FiSimplest. Shortest battery life.
    Lock→Your router→App
    Bluetooth + bridgeBridge must sit close to the door.
    Lock→Plug-in bridge→Router→App
    Thread + MatterLong battery life. Needs a hub.
    Lock→Home hub→Router→Any app
    3 ways a smart lock reaches your phone. More steps isn’t worse; it’s usually the price of longer battery life.

    Built-in Wi-Fi needs nothing else, and Nuki notes it gives the shortest battery life. A Wi-Fi bridge is a small plug-in near the door. Between 2022 and 2025 my August bridges sent me about 27 “offline” emails across 3 homes. So plug it close and on its own outlet. Thread is a low-power mesh made for locks and sensors. It needs a hub (an Apple TV, HomePod, Google Nest Hub or similar). It runs under Matter, the standard that lets one lock work with Apple, Google and Alexa.

    What’s next: Aliro 1.0, a phone-as-key standard released February 26, 2026, is meant to let Apple, Google and Samsung wallets unlock any certified lock. Schlage says Sense Pro is Aliro compatible and expects Google and Samsung wallet keys once it’s certified.

    Security

    Are smart locks safe? Check the grade, keep a thumbturn inside

    A smart lock is as strong as its deadbolt. The number to look for is the ANSI/BHMA A156.40 grade for residential deadbolts. It grades Strength and Security, Durability and Finish separately, each A, B or C. “AAA” is the top grade in all 3; Level calls it the highest standard for security, durability and finish.

    AStrength and securityForced-entry tests
    ADurabilityOpen and close cycles
    AFinishWeather and corrosion
    How a BHMA “AAA” rating reads. Schlage Encode Plus and Level Lock Pro carry it; Yale Assure Lock 2 and Kwikset Aura Reach list ANSI/BHMA Grade 2.

    2 more rules I hold to

    Keep a plain thumbturn on the inside. The residential code says an exit door has to open from inside without a key or special knowledge. That’s 2021 IRC R311.2, which Washington adopts without changing that section. So skip locks that need a code or key to get out. And treat codes like keys: one per person, deleted when they leave.

    • One code per personSo the app log shows who came in, and you can delete one without changing everyone’s.
    • Turn on auto-lock with a door sensorAuto-lock without a sensor can throw the bolt into an open door.
    • Keep the app and lock updatedUpdates are how makers fix the security issues they find.
    • Keep a physical backupA key, or for keyless locks, the USB-C jumpstart and a charged power bank.

    Lockouts

    What happens when a smart lock battery dies

    You won’t be locked out without warning. Every lock above warns you in the app and at the door for days or weeks first. If it does run flat, each lock has a way in:

    1. 01Warnings startApp alerts, beeps or a red light at the door.
    2. 02Use the keyMost keypad locks and every retrofit keep a key.
    3. 03Or jump itSense Pro has USB-C; some Yale models take a 9V on the front.
    4. 04Swap the batteriesFrom inside, then test the bolt.
    From the first warning to fresh batteries. Retrofits keep your old key, so a dead lock is just a regular deadbolt.

    Rentals and second homes

    Smart locks for rentals, Airbnbs and second homes

    Smart locks earn their keep on homes you aren’t at. From anywhere, you can give a cleaner, a contractor or a guest their own code and delete it when the job ends. The app log shows who came and went.

    CodeMonTueWedThuFriSatSun
    Guest A
    Cleaner
    Guest B
    Owner
    An illustrative week at a rental: each guest’s code works only from check-in to checkout, the cleaner’s only for the turnover, and only the owner’s code is permanent.

    Landlords

    If you’re a Washington landlord, the law asks you to provide reasonably adequate locks and furnish keys to the tenant. You must also safeguard any master or duplicate keys (RCW 59.18.060). A smart lock counts as a lock; treat its codes and app access like those duplicate keys.

    Far-off homes

    For a far-off home, choose built-in Wi-Fi or a Thread hub you trust, and the longest battery rating you can get. Add a door sensor so you know the door is shut, not just locked. More on that home: my Lake Cushman guide.

    Buying or selling

    Moving in or selling: reset, rekey and match your keys

    Whatever a home came with, assume the last owner still knows a code. This is the list I send buyers after closing:

    1. 01Factory-reset the smart lockThen add your own codes and phones, and recalibrate.
    2. 02Buy any new locks firstSo the locksmith installs them in one visit.
    3. 03Rekey everything to one keyMatch the key type (Schlage, Kwikset or Yale).
    4. 04Add the mailboxAbout $75 more if the locksmith is already there.
    My post-closing lock list. A mobile locksmith does all of it in one visit.

    Condos: some buildings treat a new lock as a change to the hallway look and want board approval first. Some use restricted keys only the owner on record can copy. Ask the manager before you buy.

    Selling: leave the lock, remove your phones from the app, and hand the buyer the manual or model number. More on what to do before you move in: my move-in address checklist.

    FAQ

    Frequently asked questions about smart locks

    Which smart lock is best for a front door?

    For most homes, a keypad deadbolt with built-in Wi-Fi and AA batteries. I recommend the Yale Assure Lock 2 with Wi-Fi; Schlage Encode Plus if you want the toughest rating and Apple Home Key.

    Are smart locks safe?

    As safe as the deadbolt they’re built on. Look for an ANSI/BHMA A156.40 grade (AAA is the top), keep codes one per person, and keep the app updated.

    Can a smart lock be hacked?

    Any connected device can have flaws, which is why makers ship updates. The everyday risks are simpler: shared codes nobody deletes and old owners’ phones still in the app.

    What happens if the battery dies?

    You get days or weeks of warnings first. Then use the key, or jump keyless locks like Schlage Sense Pro with a USB-C cable.

    How long do smart lock batteries last?

    Makers rate 3 months (August Wi-Fi) to up to a year (Yale Assure Lock 2, Level Lock Pro). Wi-Fi, a busy door and cold weather shorten it.

    Can I add a smart lock without changing my deadbolt?

    Yes. A retrofit (August, Nuki, Level Bolt) replaces only the inside half, so your keys and outside look stay.

    Which smart locks work with Apple Home Key?

    Schlage Encode Plus, Level Lock Pro, Yale Assure Lock 2 Plus and Kwikset Halo Select Plus, among others. Schlage Sense Pro adds hands-free unlock.

    Do smart locks work with Ring, Alexa or Google?

    Most work with Alexa and Google. Matter locks (Kwikset Aura Reach, Level, Nuki, Sense Pro) work across Apple, Google and Alexa through one standard.

    Do I need a hub or bridge?

    Not with built-in Wi-Fi. Thread and Matter locks need a home hub such as an Apple TV, HomePod or Google Nest Hub.

    Can I use lithium batteries in a smart lock?

    Only if the maker says so. Schlage says its locks aren’t compatible with lithium; August’s Wi-Fi lock uses CR123 lithium cells.

    Should I change the locks when I buy a house?

    Yes. Factory-reset any smart lock, then have a mobile locksmith rekey everything to one key, mailbox included.

    Can a renter install a smart lock?

    Ask the landlord first; a retrofit is the easy yes because the outside and keys don’t change. In Washington the landlord is responsible for locks and keys (RCW 59.18.060).

    The bottom line

    Pick the type first, then the brand. For most Seattle front doors that means a keypad deadbolt with Wi-Fi and AA batteries. I put the Yale Assure Lock 2 on my own doors. Keep a thumbturn inside, give everyone their own code, and change batteries on a calendar.

    Want help with the rest of the house? My smart home setup and the home care how-tos are a good next stop.

    Sources

    Previous
    Previous

    Should You Caulk Around a Toilet? What Seattle’s Plumbing Code Says and How to Do It

    Next
    Next

    What Grows Well in Seattle? The Fruit I Harvest at Home and What to Plant